Liquidity and Technology

Markets will generally continue to grapple with an environment of capital superabundance. Even with moderating financial growth in developed markets, the fundamental forces that inflated the global balance sheet since the 1980s—financial innovation, high-speed computing and reliance on leverage—are still in place.

There certainly has been a great deal of liquidity in the two years.  This is likely to continue over the next several years, and maybe well into the next decade. Policies that implicitly or explicitly constrained growth in median household income relative to GDP are more to blame than the changes in the financial system because these plosives tended to force up the savings rate. The financial system changes are much more likely to be consequences rather than causes of abundant liquidity, although there is plenty of historical evidence to suggest that the two come together, and that they are mutually reinforcing.

Technology “revolutions” tend to take place when a huge amount of risk-seeking capital flows into very risky and often capital-intensive high-tech investments, generating large network benefits and creating tremendous rewards for successful technology ventures. Particularly for those technology projects that benefit from growing networks — railroads, telephones, video, the internet — there is a strong element of pro-cyclicality, in that early successes spur greater visibility and faster adoption, which of course creates further success.

What today we call economic globalization — a combination of rapid technological progress, large-scale capital flows, and burgeoning international trade — has happened many times before in the last 200 years. During each of these periods (including our own), engineers and entrepreneurs became folk heroes and made vast fortunes while transforming the world around them. They exploited scientific advances, applied a succession of innovations to older discoveries, and spread the commercial application of these technologies throughout the developed world. Communications and transportation were usually among the most affected areas, with each technological surge causing the globe to “shrink” further.  As a historical rule it was primarily commerce and finance that drove globalization, not science or technology, and certainly not politics or culture.

Are we in such a period? We certainly were before the 2007-08 crisis, but every globalization period has been followed by a contraction which, too, has certain characteristics in common.

This disruption has already occurred to some extent. After 2007-08, global GDP growth dropped sharply, the growth in global trade dropped even more sharply, we have seen soaring unemployment, and I expect that we will soon see a wave of sovereign defaults.

But this time may be different in one important way. The 2007-08 crisis may well be the first global crisis that has occurred in a period of credible fiat currency.  The Liquidity Issue

Liquidity

 

Clinton, Goldman Sachs and Greece

Eaglevale Partners LP, which is run by Hillary Clinton’s son-in-law, Marc Mezvinsky,  bet big on a turnaround in the Greece economy — and lost.

“Eaglevale Partners LP, founded by Marc Mezvinsky and two former colleagues from Goldman Sachs Group Inc., told investors in a letter sent last week they had been ‘incorrect’ on Greece, helping produce losses for the firm’s main fund during two of the past three years. The main fund dropped 3.6% last year, far trailing the 5.7% rise for similar hedge funds tracked by HFR Inc. … A smaller Eaglevale fund focused only on Greece plunged 48% last year, said the person familiar with the situation, hurt by the belief Greece’s economy will see a quick rebound.”

But perhaps most revealing is this fact: The CEO of Goldman Sachs is a key investor in the fund:

Among investors in Eaglevale’s main fund is Goldman Sachs Chairman and Chief Executive Lloyd Blankfein , people familiar with the matter said.

Blankfein appears key to the enterprise because, well, Goldman Sachs has helped raise capital for the fund:.  From the start, Eaglevale’s moves have been closely followed, investors said, partly because of Mr. Mezvinsky’s family connection. Ahead of the firm’s launch, Goldman Sachs hosted group sessions for prospective investors that drew standing-room-only crowds. The investment bank is one of the firm’s prime brokers, which help hedge funds execute trades and introduce them to potential backers.

The founders’ pedigree helped raise them money, investors said. One of Mr. Mezvinsky’s partners, Bennett Grau, got his start at J. Aron & Co., the commodity-trading arm that produced many of Goldman Sachs’s current leaders, including Mr. Blankfein.

The EU has not forgotten Goldman’s role in Greece’s misrepresentations to the EU in 2002.  Greece’s debt managers agreed to a huge deal with the savvy bankers of Goldman Sachs at the start of 2002. The deal involved so-called cross-currency swaps in which government debt issued in dollars and yen was swapped for euro debt for a certain period — to be exchanged back into the original currencies at a later date.

Such transactions are part of normal government refinancing. Europe’s governments obtain funds from investors around the world by issuing bonds in yen, dollar or Swiss francs. But they need euros to pay their daily bills. Years later the bonds are repaid in the original foreign denominations.

But in the Greek case the US bankers devised a special kind of swap with fictional exchange rates. That enabled Greece to receive a far higher sum than the actual euro market value of 10 billion dollars or yen. In that way Goldman Sachs secretly arranged additional credit of up to $1 billion for the Greeks.

This credit disguised as a swap didn’t show up in the Greek debt statistics. Eurostat’s reporting rules don’t comprehensively record transactions involving financial derivatives. “The Maastricht rules can be circumvented quite legally through swaps,” says a German derivatives dealer.

Of course being related to a former president and perhaps future president has apparently been helpful to Mezvinsky’s enterprise as well.

Goldman, Clinton, Greece

 

No Bridge Loans for Greece

Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras will chart a path forward for Greece in parliament on Sunday, two days after the head of the euro-area finance ministers’ group shot down his proposal to avoid being shut off from funding at the end of the month.

The new government’s request for a debt writedown has already been rejected, and Eurogroup chief Jeroen Dijsselbloem on Friday rejected a request for a short-term financing agreement to keep the country afloat while it renegotiates the terms of its bailout program.

“We don’t do” bridge loans, Dijsselbloem told reporters in The Hague, when asked about Greece’s request. “A simple extension is possible as long as they fully take over the program.”

 The European Union’s latest rebuff raises the stakes for Greece’s new government. The next showdown is scheduled for Feb. 11 in Brussels, when Greek Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis faces his 18 euro-area counterparts in an emergency meeting after Tsipras delivers his major policy address to lawmakers.

Standard & Poor’s lowered Greece’s long-term credit rating one level to B- and kept the ratings on CreditWatch negative.

“Liquidity constraints have narrowed the timeframe during which Greece’s new government can reach an agreement with its official creditors on a financing program, in our view,” S&P said in a statement.

Greece’s goal remains to achieve a bridge program that would give it time to negotiate with its creditors and devise a three- to four-year fiscal plan.

Varoufakis has said his government won’t accept any more cash under the terms of Greece’s existing bailout, leaving 7 billion euros of potential aid on the table, rather than complying with demands for more austerity attached to the country’s international bailout agreement.

The standoff risks leaving Europe’s most-indebted state without any funding as of the end of this month, following the Jan. 25 election victory of Tsipras’s Syriza party.

While there’s little doubt Tsipras will win the confidence vote — his coalition has 162 seats in the 300-seat chamber — attempts to persuade the rest of the euro-region to endorse his plan to restructure the country’s debt and boost spending have so far drawn a blank. Tsipras and Varoufakis, have been recalibrating their rhetoric this week after markets plunged during their first days in office.

No Bridge Loans

Alibaba Does More Than Phone In India

Ant Financial Services Group, an affiliate of China’s Alibaba Group Holding Ltd, has agreed to buy 25 percent of Indian payment services provider One97 Communications, tapping into the country’s smartphone and online industry boom.

The companies did not provide the value of the deal, but a person with knowledge of the matter called the investment a precursor to One97 listing on the stock exchange, and said the stake was worth more than $500 million.

The deal values One97 at more than $2 billion, making it one of the most-valuable start ups in the country. One97 runs Paytm, an online platform through which users can shop or pay utility bills, whereas Ant runs Paytm’s Chinese peer Alipay.

Paytm has benefited from the spread of affordable handsets and internet connectivity which has turned India into the fastest-growing smartphone market in the Asia-Pacific region, according to researcher IDC.

“This partnership between Ant Financial Services Group and Paytm will foster the growth of India’s digital payment ecosystem,” the companies said in a joint statement.

Ant, investing in an Indian company for the first time, will provide Paytm “with strategic and technical support for its business”, the companies said.

One97 plans to use the proceeds to grow its mobile payment business and increase the scale of its services, they said.

“With over one billion people, India’s payments market has vast untapped potential,” Ant Vice President Cyril Han said in the statement.

Paytm has about 23 million users, the companies said. The $2 billion valuation of operator One97 compares with the $11 billion of Flipkart Online Services Pvt Ltd, India’s biggest e-commerce company.

Ant to India

Should Obama Mind his own Business?

Ashoka Mody writes: President Barack Obama’s recent call to ease the austerity imposed on Greece is remarkable – and not only for his endorsement of the newly elected Greek government’s negotiating position in the face of its official creditors. Obama’s comments represent a break with the long-standing tradition of official American silence on European monetary affairs. (Note: It is unfortunate that the American who speaks up knows so little of his own country’s finances).

German Chancellor Angela Merkel said that Greece should not expect more debt relief and must maintain austerity. Meanwhile, after days of not-so-veiled threats, the European Central Bank is on the verge of cutting funding to Greek banks. The guardians of financial stability are amplifying a destabilizing bank run.

The International Monetary Fund has acquiesced in German-imposed orthodoxy. As IMF Managing Director Christine Lagarde told the Irish Times: “A debt is a debt, and it is a contract. Defaulting, restructuring, changing the terms has consequences.”

Delays and errors in managing the Greek crisis started early. In July 2010, Lagarde, who was France’s finance minister at the time, recognized the damage incurred by those initial delays.  Even the IMF acknowledged that it had been a mistake not to impose losses on private creditors preemptively; it finally did so only in June 2013, when the damage had already been done.

There is plenty of blame to go around. Former US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner championed a hardline stance against debt restructuring during a crisis.

Lee Buchheit, a leading sovereign-debt attorney  was harshly critical of the authorities’ failure to face up to reality.

Obama may have arrived late to the right conclusion, but he expressed what should be an obvious truth: “You cannot keep on squeezing countries that are in the midst of depression.”

Recent analysis shows that forgiveness of Greece’s official debt is unambiguously desirable.. If European sensitivities must be assuaged, Greece’s debt repayment could be drawn out over 100 years.

At the end of the day, debt forgiveness benefits creditors as much as it helps debtors. Creditors have known this since Spain’s King Philip II became the world’s first known serial sovereign defaulter.

European authorities must come to understand that the next act of the Greek tragedy will not be confined to Greece. If relief fails to materialize, political discontent will spread, extremist forces will gain strength, and the survival of the European Union itself could be endangered.

 End of Austerity in Greece

Win Win Gender Diversity in Silicon Valley?

Kristin V. Brown writes:  As criticisms of Silicon Valley’s largely white male ranks came to a boil last spring, Nicole Sanchez was in the midst of launching a company of her own — a consultancy to help companies’ diversity.

The timing couldn’t have been better. The month Vaya Consulting opened, Google released its lackluster employee diversity data to the public. At Vaya, the calls came pouring in. One company’s public relations nightmare, it turns out, is another woman’s startup.

Vaya is one of a host of upstarts seeking to turn Silicon Valley’s diversity problem into profit — helping tech companies find, recruit and retain a diverse workforce, usually for a hefty fee. Still other companies have recently added diversity services to those already offered.

In tech, diversity is now for sale.

Sanchez and her team helps clients like Pinterest with tasks such as restructuring recruitment and organizing bias training.

At Pinterest, a scrapbooking social network that has a majority of female users, the numbers are a bit better than elsewhere in tech. Overall, 92 percent of its staff is either white or Asian, but 40 percent of the more than 300 employees are women.

But Pinterest suspected that lurking in its hiring and recruiting strategies might be practices that made it harder for female, black, Latino and Native American candidates to make the cut. The company signed deals last week with Vaya, and another startup, Paradigm, to revamp the way it phrases job postings and interview questions.

Gap Jumpers, another diversity startup, sells software that helps tech companies evaluate job candidates based on talent alone.

Sound company Dolby Labs, one of Gap Jumpers’ clients, said it recently hired an engineering intern who probably would have otherwise been passed over due to a lack of experience and academic pedigree.

Gap Jumpers was started in June, and already has eight paying clients and six more testing its product. Its customers pay an annual fee of $2,000 for each hiring manager using the software.

Textio is a new company whose software detects patterns in job postings that might turn off candidates who aren’t white and male.

Entelo, a recruiting software company, added a feature in May that allows hiring managers to run searches for diverse job candidates with specific skills, such as a female software developer with expertise in JavaScript. Annual subscriptions start at $10,000.

Piazza, which makes software that college students use to communicate with professors, introduced a product last fall that lets technology companies find women taking computer science classes. The cost of that service starts at $100,000 a year.

Likewise, Sanchez, of Vaya Consulting, said she has been turning business away — too many companies seem to think hiring her will be a quick solution to a complicated problem.

Gender Diversity in Silicon Valley

Nigeria’s Bonds?

Nigeria having a tough time as oil prices plummet. Yet  Nigeria will probably remain in JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s local-currency emerging-market bond indexes tracked by over $200 billion of funds, according to the central bank governor.

“The main issue was liquidity and we are convinced that liquidity has come up to the level they desire,” Governor Godwin Emefiele said by phone from Abuja. “It’s gone to a range of about $250 million to $300 million a day.”

JPMorgan placed Africa’s largest economy and oil producer on “index watch negative’’ for its GBI-EM indexes on Jan. 16, saying central bank measures in December had reduced foreign exchange and bond trading and made it difficult for investors to replicate the gauge. The New-York based lender said it would make a decision within five months.
Nigeria, which derives 90 percent of export earnings and 70 percent of government revenue from oil, has been battered by crude prices that have fallen by half since June.
The central bank increased interest rates to a record 13 percent in November in a bid to stem outflows and stabilize the naira, which has weakened 17 percent against the dollar in the past six months,

Nigeria's Bonds

Whistleblowers of the World Unite?

In the original case against UBS there was one indispensible person:  Bradley Birkenfeld.  He had to do time, in jail and then at home with an electronic bracelet.  But he also received $104 million from the Internal Revenue Service for making possible the collection of billions of dollars in unpaid taxes.

Why haven’t more people become whistleblowers?  They are often the difference between prosecuting a case and not starting an action.  They are certainly instrumental in winning cases.  And people who blow the whistle can make huge sums of money.

It is a frightening action to take.  You are going up against big companies and often ending your chance of being employed in your business of choice.  The prospect of prison is also a deterrent.

Should governments consider amnesty for people who are willing to step up and expose the criminal cultures of the institutions in which they work?  Transparency International writes: Whistleblowers are invaluable in exposing corruption, fraud and mismanagement. Early disclosure of wrongdoing or the risk of wrongdoing can protect human rights, help to save lives and preserve the rule of law.

Safeguards also protect and encourage people willing to take the risk of speaking out about corruption. We must push countries to introduce comprehensive whistleblower legislation to protect those that speak out and ensure that their claims are properly investigated. Companies, public bodies and non-profit organisations should introduce mechanisms for internal reporting. And workplace reprisals against whistleblowers should be seen as another form of corruption.

Public education is also essential to de-stigmatise whistleblowing, so that citizens understand how disclosing wrongdoing benefits the public good. When witnesses of corruption are confident about their ability to report it, corrupt individuals cannot hide behind the wall of silence.

Jeff Koterba cartoon for June 18, 2013 "Whistle Blower"

Russia Update

Alexander Winning and Oksana Kobzeva write:  Russian banks’ capital could “quickly melt” if the economy significantly weakens, but banks won’t experience significant difficulties if the situation develops in line with official forecasts, a deputy central bank governor said.

Mikhail Sukhov said banks’ loan quality could deteriorate sharply if two of the following take place: gross domestic product (GDP) falls by over 6 percent in 2015, real wages fall by over 10 percent, or if unemployment goes over 10 percent.  “I’m categorically against calling it a banking crisis,” he said. “But difficulties could emerge if economic development is significantly different from the forecasts that we have.”

The Economy Ministry last week said it expects Russia’s GDP to contract by 3 percent this year, if oil prices average $50 a barrel. Many analysts are less optimistic, predicting the economy could shrink by 5 percent or more.

Russian banks’ cost of financing and loan-loss provisioning jumped last year, hurting their profits and eroding their capital as their access to Western markets was restricted due to sanctions linked to the Ukraine crisis.  Sukhov said on Thursday that he expected Russia’s top five banks to increase their share of total banking assets to around 60 percent next year. Most of them are state-controlled, including Sberbank (SBER.MM: Quote, Profile, Research) and VTB (VTBR.MM: Quote, Profile, Research).  “The process of consolidation is going very quickly,” he said. “The concentration of business in the banking sector will strengthen.”

Russian banks’ open foreign-currency position had fallen from $14 billion to $10 billion in December, meaning their exposure to potential forex losses had reduced, Sukhov said.

The Central Bank has relaxed accounting rules and credit ratings of lenders to pre-date Russias incursion into Crimea. This means they are pretending that the economy is better than it is.

Russian Economy?

Oppenheimer, a Little Guilty?

What one hand takes away, the other hand gives.  The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has voted to give Oppenheimer Holdings Inc. (NYSE:OPY) & Company a break from further enforcement action after a “bad actor” ban was triggered and then subsequently waived by an SEC commissioner’s vote.

Two of five SEC commissioners, however, are speaking out against the waiver for what they see as repeated offenses, placing law and order credentials of SEC Chairwoman Mary Jo White, a Democrat and former prosecutor, into question.   White cast the deciding vote with two Republican commissioners in favor of Oppenheimer.

Here’s the problem:  We have rules and when they are ignored, we wink and let the offending party continue doing buisness as was and is.  We are following the US Department of Labor’s decision on whether or not to waive the criminal charges levied against Credit Suisse so they can continue with their 2 billion dollar pension business in the US, despite admitting to aiding and abetting US tax evaders.

The Securities and Exchange Commission charged Oppenheimer & Co. with violating federal securities laws while improperly selling penny stocks in unregistered offerings on behalf of customers.  Oppenheimer agreed to admit wrongdoing and pay $10 million to settle the SEC’s charges. Oppenheimer will pay an additional $10 million to settle a parallel action by the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).

According to the SEC’s order instituting a settled administrative proceeding, Oppenheimer engaged in two courses of misconduct. The first involved aiding and abetting illegal activity by a customer and ignoring red flags that business was being conducted without an applicable exemption from the broker-dealer registration requirements of the federal securities laws. The customer was Gibraltar Global Securities, a brokerage firm in the Bahamas that is not registered to do business in the U.S. Oppenheimer executed sales of billions of shares of penny stocks for a supposed proprietary account in Gibraltar’s name while knowing or being reckless in not knowing that Gibraltar was actually executing transactions and providing brokerage services for its underlying customers, including many in the U.S. The SEC separately charged Gibraltar in 2013 for its alleged misconduct.

The SEC’s order finds that Oppenheimer failed to file Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) as required under the Bank Secrecy Act to report potential misconduct by Gibraltar and its customers, and the firm failed to properly report, withhold, and remit more than $3 million in backup withholding taxes from sales proceeds in Gibraltar’s account. Oppenheimer also failed to recognize the resulting liabilities and expenses in violation of the books-and-records requirements, and improperly recorded transactions for Gibraltar’s customers in Oppenheimer’s books and records.

SEC Press Release:  According to the SEC’s order, the second course of misconduct involved Oppenheimer again engaging on behalf of another customer in unregistered sales of billions of shares of penny stocks. The SEC’s investigation, which is continuing, found that the sales generated approximately $12 million in profits of which Oppenheimer was paid $588,400 in commissions. The firm’s liability stems from its failure to respond to red flags and conduct a searching inquiry into whether the sales were exempt from registration requirements of the federal securities laws, and its failure reasonably to supervise with a view toward detecting and preventing violations of the registration provisions.

The SEC’s order requires Oppenheimer to cease and desist from committing or causing any violations and any future violations of Section 15(a) and 17(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rules 17a-3 and 17a-8, and of Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933. In addition to the monetary remedies, Oppenheimer agreed to be censured and undertake such remedial measures as retaining an independent consultant to review its policies and procedures over a five-year period.  Oppenheimer Case

Design Rachel Gold

Design Rachel Gold